Fiction and the cultural meditation of ageing
Since 1945, the field of fiction has been notable for the scale of its resistance to reductive, one-dimensional narratives and images of ageing which have dominated other forms of mass media. Older writers, older readers and the subject of ageing continue to retain important and privileged positions within the fiction industry. Building on the cultural turn in social gerontology, ‘Fiction and the Cultural Mediation of Ageing’ will systematically research how older people, both as authors and readers, engage with representations of ageing. By focusing on the role this interaction plays in the shaping of self-image and social attitudes, the project team will produce an integrated analysis which will feed into direct public policy recommendations.
Philip Tew, Brunel University
Partners and Collaborators:
The primary aims of ‘Fiction and the Cultural Mediation of Ageing’ are to understand both how representations of ageing circulate in culture and society (impacting in complex ways upon social agency and policy) and how elective readership facilitates purposeful symbolic interaction with these representations, producing qualitative data through analysis of reader group diaries. The project will:
Investigate the complex processes of cultural exchange and social narrative involved in understanding the experience of ageing within the contemporary period. Research will concentrate on the field of fiction and its part in narratives of identity, agency and social norms. The investigators will analyse the changing cultural contours of ageing in contemporary Britain variously, including by exploring (i) changing fictional representations of ageing during the post-war period, (ii) the role of representation in reflecting and shaping social and personal attitudes towards ageing amongst older people, and society more generally, and, (iii) the changing social and ideological understanding of ageing, as revealed by a longitudinal qualitative social survey undertaken by Mass Observation, and the specific attitudes of readers and writers of fiction in reading groups as co-researchers.
Investigate elective readership as a form of social agency. A wide range of qualitative data will be collected from authors, readers and participants in the Mass-observation life-writing project. In particular, reading diaries will be kept by members of the reading groups which will be formed in association with the Third Age Trust. These diaries will provide direct evidence concerning how the practices and strategies of active reading process representations of ageing, and detail the participant’s views of social contexts in which ageing is configured. The critical discussion within these reading groups, led by moderators and involving on occasions participant observation from the three investigators and a Demos researcher, will enable the same practices and strategies to be applied to the representations that implicitly underlie social policy issues concerning ageing and the elderly.
The three key objectives of the project are:
to give voice to older people and produce an adaptable framework for user-group activity. By bringing together reading group members with writers and policy-makers in a series of public events, we will ensure that older people are heard and illustrate how a model of active readership can restore symbolic capital to the elderly and directly benefit society in general: a virtuous circle which could be repeated in many locations.
to make the insights revealed by this study directly available to, and readily usable by, policy-makers at all levels of British society. Collaboration with the think tank Demos is central to this objective, guaranteeing high-profile presentation and dissemination of the research in the form of a substantial policy report that will be co-written by a Demos researcher and the project investigators.
to create a lasting academic legacy for both the project itself and for this kind of social research within the Humanities. The findings and analytical models established by the project will be disseminated through a major international conference and a path-breaking critical monograph written by the three investigators. It will attempt to demonstrate that the rich inheritance of critical approaches possessed by the humanities integrated with those drawn from the social sciences can be expanded beyond traditional humanities interests to meet the complex social needs of 21st Century Britain.
Reader Study: In collaboration with the Third Age Trust, seven volunteer reading groups will be set up under the jurisdiction of the Greater London Forum of University of the Third Age (U3A) districts. The U3A network provides active readers, across the retired age range, experienced in self-organised informal learning. Group coordinators will be recruited through existing U3A channels and will act as the principle point of contact between group members and the investigators. The groups will be supplied with a series of post-war and contemporary texts (such as David Lodge’s Deaf Sentence and Barbara Pym’s Quartet in Autumn) and their discussions, guided by the coordinator, will treat fictional representations as a stimulus to wider debate. Over the course of the study, discussions will range across many areas of policy concern, such as social isolation, dignity, disability and dependency. Group members will maintain anonymous reading diaries throughout exploring both their encounters with texts and the group discussions engendered by them. These will be collected at intervals and complemented with semi-structured interviews. Group members will be asked to consider themselves as co-researchers within the project and be invited to participate in events and the project conference, including live dialogue with authors.
Social Attitudes Study: This component of the project comprises both archival research and the commissioning of a new directive in autumn 2009 to the MO panel concerning books, book groups and representations of ageing (51% of respondents to the spring 2007 directive were over 60). In keeping with successful MO practice, the directive will be framed broadly to elicit a wide variety of discursive and critical reflections. Analysis of the resultant material will not only complement the reader study but be further comparable with the responses to earlier directives from the contemporary MO project (1981 to the present), enabling a longitudinal study of social attitudes to ageing and their relationship with cultural representations of ageing. This longitudinal research will draw on the replies to the questions concerning ageing issued first as part of the winter 1992 directive and then repeated again, in almost identical format, in autumn 2006. This material is particularly useful for showing generational shifts in the dating of the key changes of life and the understanding of what being old means to particular individuals. Initial analysis of this data and some of the material written in response to directives concerning issues of reading, writing and literacy practices in 1983, 1991, 1993 and 2003, will inform the drafting of the autumn 2009 directive. Subsequent detailed analysis of all this material and the incoming directive replies will play a crucial role in mapping the complex process of socio-cultural interaction that has shaped the experience of ageing within the post-war period.
Author Study: Authors will be addressed as active cultural and social agents operating in a field of cultural capital through a series of semi-structured interviews. Not only will the focus be to consider ageing as both a fictional engagement, and as part of their professional and life experiences, but the selected writers will be encouraged to consider their role as public intellectuals in debates wider than the literary. Given their potentially significant role as producers and social agents, such authors are recognized both formally and informally as contributors to the literary zeitgeist and, in a broader sense, to the symbolic economy within which frameworks of cultural value evolve. The study will draw upon these interviews together with associated literary-biographical and other data. It will feed into an integrated analysis including findings from the reader and Mass Observation studies, which will incorporate analysis of the role of authors in mediating and shaping the cultural field.
An adaptable framework for user-group activity. A model for user-group activity, drawing on the good practice of the Third Age Trust and Mass Observation, will be established that can be replicated at different levels around the country as a form of participatory democracy and social engagement for all groups in society, but particularly for those across the retired age range.
A policy report published by Demos. A Demos researcher will be actively involved with the project from the beginning: assisting with the training session for reader group coordinators, attending some of the reading group sessions, attending author-reader events and analyzing research findings before co-authoring a Demos report with the project investigators. This report will take a narrative approach to the project’s research findings and seek to show (a) how narrative tropes of older people drive policy, (b) how older people respond (critically and imaginatively) to these tropes and (c) how these stories provide a platform for rethinking policy. According to the usual Demos procedure, emergent findings will be publicly discussed with key stakeholders at a high-level policy seminar organised by Demos in central London in order to ensure maximum effectiveness for the final draft. Demos will also organize a public launch and facilitate media coverage for the finished report. The report will be available freely on the Demos website: comparable publications have achieved download rates in excess of 80,000.
Academic publications and methodological legacy. The project investigators will co-author a socio-cultural study synthesizing the project’s innovative methodological mix. Offering a fresh model of engagement with post-war representations of ageing, this study will draw on the author interviews, reader study and Mass Observation research to produce a path-breaking publication within literary studies and social sciences. The monograph will be placed with a major academic publisher in order to secure a lasting academic legacy for the project and its research methods.
Events series. During the life of the project the investigators will run a series of activities and events including author participation and an academic network seminar series, culminating in a major two-day conference, aimed at engaging participants, stakeholders and user groups.
‘Fiction and the Cultural Mediation of Ageing’ employs an innovative methodological bricolage, drawing on a range of research techniques from both the Humanities and Social Sciences. In policy terms, these elements will be brought together in an integrated analysis, tightly targeted at the policy community through a close collaboration with the think tank Demos. Key outcomes from this collaboration will include a policy report which will be made available freely through the Demos website, and the hosting of a high level policy seminar to which key interest groups, stakeholders and media will be invited.
1. Key policy and/or practice implications of the research
The project will (1) give voice older people, (2) offer recommendations and make insights directly available to stakeholders and policy makers (3) develop an innovative model for social research in the Humanities. The key means through which this will be achieved are by:
2. Key non-academic user groups that will be targeted
Older people generally The Third Age Trust / U3A (nationally) The Centre for Policy on Ageing (CPA) Age Concern and Help the Aged CAADE Employers Forum on Age Independent Age National Pensioners Convention (NPC) Policy Research Institute on Ageing and Ethnicity (PRIAE) The Age and Employment Network (TAEN) All Party Parliamentary Group on Ageing and Older People
3. Assistance needed from the NDA programme in this targeting
More information on the Fiction and the cultural meditation of ageing project can be found on their website